Laser Type Selection Guide: Comparative Analysis of Pulsed, Continuous, and QCW Lasers
In modern industrial manufacturing, medical aesthetics, scientific research, and other fields, the laser is the core light source equipment, and its type selection directly determines processing quality and production efficiency. Based on their energy output waveform, lasers fall into three major categories: continuous wave (CW) lasers, pulsed lasers, and quasi-continuous wave (QCW) lasers. This article provides a systematic comparison across four dimensions — working principle, characteristics, technical parameters, and application scenarios — as a professional selection reference for industry practitioners.
1. Continuous Wave Lasers (CW Lasers)
1.1 Definition and Working Principle
A continuous wave (CW) laser is a laser that outputs a stable energy waveform continuously throughout its operating time. Its core feature is that the pump source supplies energy continuously, keeping the gain medium in a steady population inversion state; the output laser is a continuous, stable beam whose energy is evenly distributed over time.
Key points of the working principle:
– Continuous pumping: the laser medium is continuously electrically driven or continuously illuminated, so the population inversion remains stable and unbroken
– Uniform output: laser energy is evenly distributed over time, like water flowing steadily from an open tap
– Stable gain: no energy storage-and-release mechanism is needed, and the output power is highly stable
1.2 Core Characteristics
| Characteristic | Description |
| Output mode | Continuous uninterrupted beam with energy evenly distributed over time |
| Power range | Wide coverage, from the milliwatt level to tens of kilowatts |
| Peak power | Close to the average power, typically at the W~kW level |
| Thermal effect | Significant; continuous energy input easily heats and deforms the material |
| Beam quality | Usually good (M²≤1.5~2.0) |
| Energy distribution | Gaussian or flat-top distribution |
1.3 Key Technical Parameters (Mainstream Products as Examples)
Table 1-1 Typical technical parameters of CW fiber lasers
| Parameter | Typical value | Description |
| Operating wavelength | 1064nm (infrared) / 1070nm | Main band of fiber lasers |
| Output power | 100W-100kW | From precision machining to heavy industry |
| Beam quality M² | ≤1.5 (single-mode) / ≤2.0 (multimode) | Determines the focusing capability |
| Power stability | ≤±1.5% | Power fluctuation over long-term operation |
| Electro-optical efficiency | 30%-45% | Fiber lasers are relatively efficient |
| Cooling method | Water cooling | Required for high power |
Manufacturer product reference (Source: Raycus official website):
– CW fiber laser power covers 10W to 30,000W
– HP series high-performance CW lasers: 300-40000W
– Global version series: single module 1kW-12kW, multi-module 20kW-100kW
1.4 Typical Application Scenarios
1. Sheet metal cutting: efficient cutting of thick steel plate, carbon steel, and stainless steel
2. Laser welding: continuous seam welding of car bodies, ships, and metal structural parts
3. Laser cladding: surface repair and strengthening of worn parts
4. Fiber-optic communication: stable signal light source
5. Additive manufacturing: metal 3D printing
1.5 Advantages of CW Lasers
– Efficient and stable: continuous output ensures processing efficiency, suitable for large-scale production
– Deep-penetration welding: high power density achieves deep-penetration welds with aspect ratios above 8:1
– Thick material processing: suitable for continuous forming of materials over 1mm thick
– Cost advantage: relatively simple structure and lower operation and maintenance cost
– Easy commissioning: the main parameters are the power waveform, defocus amount, spot core diameter, and welding speed
2. Pulsed Lasers
2.1 Definition and Working Principle
A pulsed laser is a device that emits laser light intermittently and periodically, delivering energy in the form of pulses. Unlike CW lasers, a pulsed laser releases high-peak-power laser pulses within extremely short durations (nanoseconds, picoseconds, or even femtoseconds).
Core of the working principle — energy storage and rapid release:
“`
Pump excitation → population inversion → energy storage (Q-switching/mode-locking) → rapid release → laser pulse output
“`
Two main pulse generation techniques:
| Technique | Principle | Pulse width | Typical applications |
| Q-switching | Rapidly changes the Q factor of the laser cavity so that accumulated energy is released instantly | Nanosecond (ns) | Industrial marking, engraving |
| Mode-locking | Locks the phases of different longitudinal modes inside the laser cavity | Picosecond-femtosecond (ps/fs) | Ultrafast lasers, scientific research |
Q-switching techniques in detail:
– Electro-optic Q-switching: uses the linear electro-optic effect (KDP crystals, etc.) to achieve a sudden change of the Q factor, with short switching time and high efficiency
– Acousto-optic Q-switching: uses the acoustic diffraction effect to deflect the beam and modulate the cavity loss
– Saturable-absorber Q-switching: automatically modulated by saturable absorbers such as SESAM
2.2 Pulsed Laser Classification and Parameters
Table 2-1 Classification by pulse width
| Type | Pulse width | Peak power | Thermal effect | Typical applications |
| Nanosecond lasers | 1-1000ns | kW-MW class | Small | Laser marking, deep engraving, cleaning |
| Picosecond lasers | 1-1000ps | MW class | Very small | Precision micromachining, tattoo removal |
| Femtosecond lasers | <1ps (10⁻¹⁵s) | GW-TW class | Almost none | Eye surgery, chip etching, aero-engine micro-hole drilling |
Table 2-2 Typical parameters of MOPA pulsed fiber lasers (Source: Maxphotonics official website)
| Parameter | MFPT-100M+ | MFPT-200M+ | MFPT-300M+ |
| Max average power | ≥100W | ≥200W | ≥300W |
| Max single-pulse energy | 1.8mJ | 1.8mJ | 1.8mJ |
| Adjustable pulse width range | 10-500ns | 10-500ns | 10-500ns |
| Repetition rate range | 1-4000kHz | 1-4000kHz | 1-4000kHz |
| Beam quality M² | 1.6 (typ. 1.3) | 1.6 (typ. 1.3) | 1.6 (typ. 1.3) |
| Power stability | <5% | <5% | <5% |
| Cooling method | Air cooling | Air cooling | Air cooling |
Table 2-3 Raycus MOPA pulsed fiber laser parameters (Source: Raycus official website)
| Model | RFL-P100MX | RFL-P200MX |
| Rated output power | 100W | 200W |
| Center wavelength | 1064nm | 1064nm |
| Pulse width range | 2-500ns | 2-500ns |
| Repetition rate range | 1-2000kHz | 1-2000kHz |
| Max single-pulse energy | 1mJ | 1mJ |
| Peak power | ≤15kW | ≤15kW |
| M² | <1.6 | <1.6 |
| Cooling method | Air cooling | Air cooling |
Table 2-4 High-power pulsed laser parameters (Source: Raycus R-P1000H)
| Parameter | Value |
| Average output power | 1000W |
| Center wavelength | 1064±5nm |
| Pulse width range | 20-100ns |
| Repetition rate range | 10-100kHz |
| Single-pulse energy | 100mJ |
| Peak power | 1MW |
| Beam quality BPP | <25 mm*mrad |
| Cooling method | Water cooling |
2.3 Key Performance Parameters Explained
Pulse width — the core indicator
Pulse width is the duration of a single pulse and directly determines the size of the heat-affected zone:
“`
Shorter pulse → more concentrated energy → smaller heat-affected zone → higher processing precision
“`
– Femtosecond lasers achieve “heat-damage-free processing” and are suitable for precision etching of semiconductor chips
– Nanosecond lasers balance efficiency and precision, and are the mainstream choice for industrial marking
Peak power — the capability indicator
“`
Peak power = single-pulse energy ÷ pulse width
“`
Calculation example:
– Single-pulse energy: 10mJ
– Pulse width: 10ns
– Peak power = 10×10⁻³J ÷ 10×10⁻⁹s = 1MW (megawatt class)
A CW laser with the same average power has a peak power of only about 10W — a gap of 100,000 times, which is the key to why pulsed lasers can break down air and strip highly reflective materials.
Average power — a parameter shared by both types
| Type | Meaning of average power | Determining factor |
| CW laser | = actual output power | Directly determines the processing speed |
| Pulsed laser | = single-pulse energy × repetition rate | 10mJ × 1kHz = 10W |
2.4 Typical Application Scenarios
Industrial processing:
– Laser marking/engraving: high-precision marking of metals, plastics, and other materials
– Precision cutting/drilling: damage-free processing of brittle materials (glass, sapphire)
– Laser cleaning: surface treatment of molds, ships, and aerospace components
Medical aesthetics:
– Eye surgery: femtosecond laser myopia surgery (“another revolution in refractive surgery”)
– Skin treatment: spot removal, skin rejuvenation, tattoo removal
Scientific research:
– Ultrafast spectroscopy: studying molecular/atomic ultrafast dynamics
– LiDAR: autonomous driving and terrain surveying
Table 2-5 Pulsed laser application classification
| Application field | Recommended laser type | Core advantage |
| Precision marking | Nanosecond MOPA | High frequency, adjustable pulse width |
| Thin-film cutting | Picosecond/nanosecond | Small heat-affected zone |
| Deep engraving/cleaning | High-power nanosecond | Large pulse energy |
| Glass processing | Picosecond/femtosecond | No chipping, no cracking |
| Medical aesthetics | Nanosecond/picosecond | Precise and controllable |
2.5 Advantages of Pulsed Lasers
– High peak power: single-pulse energy density can reach 10³-10⁹ times that of CW lasers
– “Cold processing” characteristics: the pulse is so short that heat has no time to diffuse, so thermal damage to the material is minimal
– High precision: the narrower the pulse width, the higher the processing precision — femtosecond lasers reach micron or even nanometer level
– Friendly to highly reflective materials: suitable for precision processing of copper, aluminum, and other high-reflectivity materials
– Suitable for brittle materials: the first choice for precision processing of hard, brittle materials such as glass and sapphire
3. Quasi-Continuous Wave Lasers (QCW)
3.1 Definition and Working Principle
The QCW (Quasi-Continuous Wave) laser is a special type between CW lasers and pulsed lasers, capable of repeatedly delivering relatively high-energy laser output within a certain period. Strictly speaking, a QCW laser also belongs to the pulsed laser family, but with longer pulse widths (typically microsecond to millisecond) and an adjustable duty cycle.
Core principle:
A QCW laser achieves pulse output by precisely modulating the pump current, significantly increasing the peak power in pulse form while maintaining a relatively high average power. When the pulse frequency is high enough (e.g., above 50kHz), the human eye and most sensors cannot resolve individual pulses and perceive the beam as “quasi-continuous”.
3.2 Essential Differences Between QCW and CW/Pulsed Lasers
Table 3-1 QCW vs CW vs nanosecond pulsed
| Characteristic | Continuous wave (CW) laser | QCW laser | Nanosecond pulsed laser |
| Pulse width | No pulse | 0.05-50ms | 1ns-1000ns |
| Peak power | Close to the average power | About 10× the average power | 10³-10⁹ times the average power |
| Average power | High | Moderate | Relatively low |
| Repetition rate | None | Up to 50kHz | 1Hz to several MHz |
| Thermal effect | Large | Moderate (cooling between pulses) | Very small |
| Typical scenarios | Thick plate cutting, deep-penetration welding | Medium-thick plate, precision welding, drilling | Precision micromachining, marking |
Energy output waveform comparison:
“`
CW laser: ████████████████████████████████ (duty cycle=1)
QCW laser: ███░░░░░████░░░░░████░░░░░████░░ (duty cycle≈10%)
Nanosecond pulse: █░░░████░░░░████░░░░░████░░░░░█ (duty cycle<<1%)
```
3.3 Core Technical Parameters of QCW Lasers
Table 3-2 Typical parameters of IPG QCW fiber lasers (Source: IPG Photonics official website)
| Parameter | YLS-QCW | YLR-QCW | YLM-QCW |
| Wavelength | 1070nm | 1070nm | 1070nm |
| Multimode average power | Up to 2kW | Up to 450W | Up to 600W |
| Single-mode average power | – | – | – |
| Peak power | Up to 20kW | Up to 4.5kW | Up to 6kW |
| Pulse energy | Up to 240J | Up to 45J | Up to 60J |
| Pulse duration | 0.2-10ms | 0.05-50ms | 0.05-50ms |
| Pulse frequency | Up to 2kHz | Up to 50kHz | Up to 50kHz |
| Cooling method | Water/air cooling | Water cooling | Water/air cooling |
Table 3-3 Raycus QCW laser parameters (Source: Raycus official website)
| Parameter | Specification |
| Power range | 75W-450W |
| Peak power | About 10× the average power |
| Pulse width | Adjustable |
| Core advantage | High peak power, low heat input |
Table 3-4 Typical application parameter configuration of QCW lasers
| Application scenario | Pulse width | Pulse frequency | Peak power |
| Battery welding | 1-10ms | 1-50Hz | Moderate |
| Precision drilling | 0.5-5ms | 10-100Hz | High |
| Thin sheet cutting | 0.1-2ms | Up to 50kHz | High |
| Surface cleaning | 0.05-1ms | Adjustable | Moderate |
3.4 Unique Advantages of QCW Lasers
1. 10× peak power characteristic
– The peak power of a QCW laser is typically about 10× the average power
– The additional pump diodes are simply connected to the active fiber
– The duty cycle is limited to 10%, greatly reducing the power supply requirement
2. “One machine, two modes” flexibility
– Combines the high peak power of pulsed lasers with the efficient stability of CW lasers
– Can flexibly switch between continuous mode and pulsed mode
– Simplifies equipment configuration and reduces the overall cost
3. Thermal management advantage
– Pulse intervals provide a “cooling mechanism”
– Effectively reduces heat accumulation and lowers the risk of thermal deformation of materials
– Defect rates such as porosity, cracks, and spatter drop significantly
4. High beam quality
– Inherits the excellent beam quality of fiber lasers
– Enables micron-level precision welding
– Suits the micro-joining needs of high-end electronics and medical devices
5. Cost effectiveness
– Lower power supply requirement than CW lasers
– Electro-optical conversion efficiency above 30%
– Maintenance-free, compact and robust design
3.5 Typical Application Scenarios
Battery manufacturing (core application):
– Tab welding, TAB welding
– Sealing pin welding
– Foil strip welding
– Precision welding of highly reflective materials such as copper and aluminum
3C electronics:
– Precision spot welding
– Butt welding of thin materials (0.2mm copper)
– Welding of micro structural parts
– Processing of heat-sensitive substrates
Aerospace:
– Turbine blade film-cooling hole drilling (key aero-engine component)
– Drilling (percussion drilling, trepanning)
– Cutting and welding
Other industrial applications:
– Laser drilling (hole diameter 0.2-1mm)
– Ceramic and sapphire cutting
– Metal surface treatment
4. Comprehensive Comparison of the Three Laser Types
4.1 Core Parameter Comparison Table
Table 4-1 Comprehensive comparison of the core parameters of the three laser types
| Comparison dimension | CW laser | QCW laser | Pulsed laser (nanosecond) | Pulsed laser (picosecond/femtosecond) |
| Output mode | Continuous and uninterrupted | Quasi-continuous pulses | Short pulse trains | Ultrashort pulses |
| Pulse width | None | 0.05-50ms | 1-1000ns | 1ps-1000fs |
| Average power | W-kW class | W-kW class | W class | mW-W class |
| Peak power | Close to the average power | 10× the average power | 10³-10⁶ times the average power | 10⁶-10⁹ times the average power |
| Repetition rate | None | Up to 50kHz | 1Hz to several MHz | 1Hz-80MHz |
| Heat-affected zone | Large | Moderate | Small | Very small/almost none |
| Processing precision | Moderate | Medium-high | High | Extremely high |
| Suitable material thickness | Thick materials (>1mm) | Medium-thick materials | Thin materials/precision parts | Ultra-thin/precision parts |
| Adaptability to highly reflective materials | Poor | Good | Good | Good |
| Equipment cost | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate | Relatively high (especially femtosecond) |
| Operation and maintenance cost | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate | Relatively high |
4.2 Energy Output Waveform Illustration
“`
Time →
CW: ████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████
↑Duty cycle 100%: continuous output with no interruption
QCW: ████████░░░░░░░░░░░░░████████░░░░░░░░░░░░░████████░░░░░░░░░░░░░
↑Duty cycle≈10%: ms-level pulse width, interval output
Nanosecond: ██░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░██░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░██░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░
↑Duty cycle≈1%: ns-level pulse width; lasing time is 1/10 of QCW
Picosecond: │░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░│░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░│░░░░░░░░
↑Duty cycle≈0.1%: ps-level pulse width; lasing time is 1/10 of nanosecond (extremely narrow, shown as vertical bars)
Femtosecond: |░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░|░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░
↑Duty cycle≈0.01%: fs-level pulse width; lasing time is 1/10 of picosecond (extremely, extremely narrow)
Progressive pattern: CW(100%) → QCW(10%) → Nanosecond(1%) → Picosecond(0.1%) → Femtosecond(0.01%)
“`
4.3 Heat-Affected Zone and Material Suitability Comparison
“`
Heat-affected zone size:
CW > QCW > nanosecond pulse > picosecond > femtosecond
Suitable material hardness:
Femtosecond > picosecond > nanosecond > QCW ≈ CW
Suitable material thickness:
CW > QCW > nanosecond > picosecond > femtosecond
“`
4.4 Application Scenario Selection Guide
Table 4-2 Selecting a laser type by application scenario
| Application scenario | Recommended laser type | Key parameter |
| Thick steel plate cutting (>6mm) | CW laser | Above 6kW |
| Medium and thin plate cutting | CW/QCW | Select by thickness |
| Deep-penetration welding of metals | CW laser | Above 1kW |
| Precision spot welding | QCW/nanosecond pulse | High peak power |
| Copper/aluminum welding | QCW | High-reflectivity resistant design |
| Precision welding of thin materials | QCW/nanosecond pulse | Low heat input |
| Laser marking | Nanosecond MOPA | Adjustable pulse width/frequency |
| Color marking on stainless steel | MOPA pulsed | Independently adjustable pulse width |
| Glass cutting | Picosecond/femtosecond | No chipping |
| Sapphire processing | Picosecond/femtosecond/nanosecond UV | Precise and controllable |
| Thin-film cutting | Nanosecond/picosecond | Low thermal effect |
| Laser cleaning | High-power nanosecond/QCW | Large pulse energy |
| Laser drilling | QCW/nanosecond pulse | High peak power |
| Medical aesthetics | Nanosecond/picosecond | Precise and controllable |
| Eye surgery | Femtosecond | Ultrashort pulses |
| Scientific research | Picosecond/femtosecond | Ultrafast dynamics |
5. Selection Recommendations and Summary
5.1 Selection Decision Tree
“`
Requirement analysis
│
├─ Is long-time continuous output required?
│ │
│ ├─ Yes → thick plate cutting, deep-penetration welding
│ │ → Recommended: CW laser
│ │
│ └─ No → is high peak power + low heat input required?
│ │
│ ├─ Yes → is extreme precision (μm level) required?
│ │ │
│ │ ├─ Yes → precision processing of glass/sapphire/chips
│ │ │ → Recommended: picosecond/femtosecond laser
│ │ │
│ │ └─ No → precision welding, drilling, marking
│ │ → Recommended: nanosecond pulsed laser (MOPA)
│ │
│ └─ No → can QCW meet the requirement?
│ │
│ ├─ Yes → battery welding, precision spot welding, medium-thick plate processing
│ │ → Recommended: QCW laser
│ │
│ └─ No → ultra-thin material precision micromachining
│ → Recommended: nanosecond/picosecond/femtosecond pulses
“`
5.2 Key Selection Considerations
1. Material characteristics
– Material type: metal, non-metal, composite
– Material thickness: determines the power requirement
– Thermal sensitivity: heat-sensitive materials prefer pulsed/QCW
– Reflectivity: avoid CW for highly reflective materials (copper, aluminum); choose QCW or pulsed
2. Processing requirements
– Precision: choose short pulses for μm-level precision
– Heat-affected zone tolerance: choose femtosecond/picosecond for strict limits
– Throughput: choose CW or high-frequency QCW for continuous processing
3. Economic evaluation
– Equipment investment: CW and nanosecond lasers offer the best value
– Operating cost: CW is efficient and saves electricity
– Maintenance cost: fiber lasers have a clear maintenance-free advantage
4. Scalability and compatibility
– Power expansion needs: reserve upgrade space
– System integration: interface compatibility
– Brand service: local support capability
5.3 Brand Product Selection Reference
Table 5-1 Product line comparison of mainstream manufacturers
| Manufacturer | CW laser | QCW laser | Pulsed laser | Ultrafast laser |
| IPG | YLS series 1-100kW | YLS-QCW/YLR-QCW 450W-2kW | – | GLPN series |
| Raycus | Flagship/HP series 10W-120kW | 75W-450W | MOPA series 10W-1000W | Nanosecond/picosecond/femtosecond |
| Maxphotonics | CW series | – | MOPA MFPT series 10W-500W | – |
| RFH | – | – | DPSS series | UV/green/infrared series |
5.4 Summary
The three laser types each have their advantages and suit different scenarios:
| Laser type | Core advantage | Best applications |
| CW laser | High power, high efficiency, deep-penetration welding capability | Thick plate cutting, deep-penetration welding, cladding |
| Pulsed laser | High peak power, cold processing, extremely high precision | Precision micromachining, marking, brittle material processing |
| QCW laser | 10× peak power, good thermal management, two modes in one machine | Battery welding, precision drilling, medium-thick plate processing |
Selection principle:
> Comprehensively evaluate material characteristics, processing precision requirements, throughput needs, and budget to choose the light source type best suited to the specific application. In actual selection, communicate fully with the technical team of the laser manufacturer and run process tests for verification to ensure the best match.
Sources and References
1. IPG Photonics – https://www.ipgphotonics.com/products/lasers/qcw-fiber-lasers
2. Raycus – https://raycuslaser.com
3. Maxphotonics – http://www.maxphotonics.com
4. RFH – http://www.rfhlasertech.com
5. Laser Fair – https://www.laserfair.com
6. Photoelectric media (光电汇) and other laser industry media outlets
*This document is intended to provide professional selection references for laser industry practitioners. For specific selection decisions, combine actual process test results with the technical support of the manufacturer.*



Leave a Reply