2.2 Depth of Focus (DOF)
Depth of focus (DOF) is the total distance on both sides of the focal point over which the spot radius grows to √2 times its value (area doubled, energy density down to 50%). Within this range the laser still maintains effective processing capability. The formula is:
DOF = 2π w02
M2λ
where w₀ = Φ₀/2 is the focused spot radius.
The smaller the spot, the shallower the DOF — that is exactly where the contradiction lies.
2.3 The Contradiction Revealed by One Formula
Substituting the spot radius w₀ = 2M²λf/(πΦ) into the DOF formula:
DOF = 2π
M2λ × (2M2λ f
πΦ)2 = 8M2λ f2
πΦ2
See it? DOF is proportional to f². Double the focal length (2×) and the depth of focus quadruples (4×); conversely, halve the focal length (1/2) and only 1/4 of the DOF remains.
This is the key the customer overlooked: a short focal length buys a small spot, but at the cost of giving up even more depth of focus.
Shorter Focal Length, Deeper Engraving? You May Have It Backwards — Balancing Focal Length, Depth of Focus and Deep Engraving
A customer asked: I need to engrave 2mm deep on a 50×50mm product — a short-focal-length F-Theta lens will do, right? A smaller spot concentrates energy, so it must engrave deeper.
The answer is: quite the opposite.
1. The Customer’s Logic — It Sounds Reasonable
The customer’s reasoning goes like this:
Short-focal-length F-Theta lens → smaller focused spot → higher energy density → deeper engraving
The first three steps are all correct. The problem is the last step: “higher energy density” does not mean “deeper engraving”.
Deep laser engraving is not a one-shot job done instantly at the focal point. The laser must peel material away layer by layer from the surface: for every 0.1mm it cuts downward, the working surface moves 0.1mm farther from the focus. And the fatal weakness of a short-focal-length F-Theta lens — too shallow a depth of focus — means that after only a few tenths of a millimeter the spot has already diverged severely, energy density falls off a cliff, and there is no way to reach 2mm deep.
2. Two Core Concepts: Focused Spot Size and Depth of Focus
2.1 Focused Spot Diameter Φ₀
The smaller the focused spot, the more concentrated the energy and the stronger the material removal capability at each spot. The formula is:
Φ0 = 4M2λ f
πΦ
– M²: beam quality factor (about 1.3~1.8 for single-mode fiber lasers)
– λ: laser wavelength (take 1.064×10⁻³mm for a 1064nm fiber laser)
– f: focal length of the F-Theta lens (mm)
– Φ: incident beam diameter (mm)
The smaller the focal length f, the smaller the spot Φ₀ — on this point the customer is right.
3. Let the Numbers Speak: Comparing Three Focal Lengths
Take a 1064nm fiber laser with M²=1.5 and an incident beam Φ=7mm (typical values for a fiber-laser galvo system):
| Parameter | F=70mm (50×50 F-Theta lens) | F=160mm (110×110 F-Theta lens) | F=254mm (175×175 F-Theta lens) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Focused spot Φ₀ | 20.3 μm | 46.4 μm | 73.7 μm |
| Spot area | 1.0 (baseline) | 5.22× | 13.17× |
| Energy density | Highest | 19% | 8% |
| Theoretical DOF | 0.406 mm | 2.12 mm | 5.35 mm |
Key findings:
– The F=70mm short-focal-length lens has a theoretical DOF of only 0.406mm — it cannot even reach 0.5mm
– The F=160mm medium-focal-length lens has a theoretical DOF of 2.12mm — it covers the 2mm depth, but energy at the bottom attenuates noticeably
– The F=254mm long-focal-length lens has a theoretical DOF of 5.35mm — ample coverage for a 2mm depth
4. What Actually Happens at 2mm Deep?
Deep engraving is not done on the focal plane; it is a layer-by-layer process descending from the surface. As depth increases, the working surface moves farther and farther from the focus, and the spot begins to diverge.
4.1 Focus on the Surface: Deeper Means Weaker
Let us calculate: with the focus set on the material surface, how does energy density change as depth increases?
F=70mm lens (Rayleigh range zR=0.203mm):
w(2mm) = w0√(1+(2/0.203)2) = w0 × 9.89
The spot area expands by 97.8×, and energy density drops to 1.0% of the focal value. At 2mm deep the laser energy is nearly zero — it cannot remove material at all.
F=160mm lens (Rayleigh range zR=1.062mm):
w(2mm) = w0√(1+(2/1.062)2) = w0 × 2.13
The spot area expands 4.55× and energy density falls to 22.0% of the focal value — barely workable, but efficiency is already very low.
F=254mm lens (Rayleigh range zR=2.676mm):
w(2mm) = w0√(1+(2/2.676)2) = w0 × 1.25
The spot area expands only 1.56×, and energy density still holds 64.2% of the focal value — still highly efficient.
The comparison is stark: at 2mm deep the short-focal-length lens has only 1% of its energy left, while the long-focal-length lens still has 64%.
But wait — the calculations above rest on one premise: the focus is set on the material surface. In real processing, experienced operators never set it up that way.
4.2 Negative Defocus: Hiding the Focus Inside the Material
Any operator who has done deep engraving knows this move: first focus on the material surface to confirm the focal position, then lower the Z axis (column) by 1mm to sink the focus inside the material, and only then start processing.
This is called negative defocus — the focus sits not on the material surface but inside the material.
Why do this? Because the energy distribution of a Gaussian beam is symmetric about the focal point: at equal distances above and below the focus, the spot size and the energy density are identical. So for a 2mm-deep job, set the focus at 1mm depth (the midpoint of the depth); then:
– The surface (z=0) is 1mm from the focus → energy density is some value
– The bottom (z=2mm) is also 1mm from the focus → energy density = exactly the same
The surface and the bottom receive identical energy density — that is the power of negative defocus.
Let the data speak: how do the three lenses perform after 1mm of negative defocus?
F=160mm lens, before and after negative defocus:
| Depth | Focus on surface | 1mm negative defocus | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0mm (surface) | 100% | 53.0% | Surface energy drops |
| 0.5mm | 81.8% | 81.8% | Unchanged |
| 1.0mm | 53.0% | 100% | Highest energy here |
| 1.5mm | 33.4% | 81.8% | ↑ Significant improvement |
| 2.0mm (bottom) | 22.0% | 53.0% | ↑ 2.4× improvement |
After negative defocus the bottom energy rises from 22% to 53% — although the surface drops from 100% to 53%, what deep engraving fears most is a bottom that cannot be cut, and insufficient surface energy can be compensated by raising the power. Moreover, from 0.5 to 2.0mm the energy stays above 53% the whole way, so uniformity improves dramatically.
F=254mm lens, before and after negative defocus:
| Depth | Focus on surface | 1mm negative defocus | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0mm (surface) | 100% | 87.7% | Only a 12% drop |
| 0.5mm | 96.6% | 96.6% | Unchanged |
| 1.0mm | 87.7% | 100% | Highest energy here |
| 1.5mm | 76.1% | 96.6% | ↑ Improved |
| 2.0mm (bottom) | 64.2% | 87.7% | ↑ 37% improvement |
After negative defocus the energy stays above 87% almost throughout — very uniform and efficient. The surface drops only from 100% to 87.7%, which barely affects processing — this is the most trouble-free option.
But for the F=70mm lens, even negative defocus cannot save it:
| Depth | Focus on surface | 1mm negative defocus |
|---|---|---|
| 0mm (surface) | 100% | 4.0% |
| 0.5mm | 14.2% | 14.2% |
| 1.0mm | 4.0% | 100% |
| 1.5mm | 1.8% | 14.2% |
| 2.0mm (bottom) | 1.0% | 4.0% |
After negative defocus the focus is indeed 100% at 1mm depth, but the surface gets only 4% and the bottom only 4% — the depth of focus is simply too shallow. The Rayleigh range is only 0.203mm, so deviating 1mm from the focus goes far beyond the effective range. It is like a flashlight beam — the spot is bright, but the illuminated range is too small to reach either end.
4.3 The Core Rule of Negative Defocus
Set the focus at the midpoint of the engraving depth — this is the most basic operating technique in deep engraving:
Offset = Target depth
2
– Engrave 2mm deep → offset 1mm
– Engrave 1mm deep → offset 0.5mm
– Engrave 3mm deep → offset 1.5mm
How to do it in practice: first focus on the material surface with the red pointer to confirm the focal position, then manually lower the Z axis/column by the corresponding distance (or set a Z-axis offset in the marking software), and start processing.
But note: negative defocus only improves the uniformity of the energy distribution; it cannot break the physical limit of the depth of focus. If a lens’s DOF is far too small to begin with (say, F=70mm for a 2mm depth), negative defocus cannot save it — energy at both the surface and the bottom is too low. The precondition for negative defocus is: the lens’s DOF must at least “reach” both ends of the engraving depth.
Now the F=254mm lens (data with the focus on the surface):
| Depth | Spot expansion factor | Energy density (% of focal value) | Actual result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0mm (surface) | 1.00x | 100% | Normal engraving |
| 0.5mm | 1.02x | 96.6% | No difference |
| 1.0mm | 1.07x | 87.7% | No difference |
| 1.5mm | 1.15x | 76.1% | Almost no difference |
| 2.0mm | 1.25x | 64.2% | Still efficient |
| 3.0mm | 1.50x | 44.3% | Acceptable |
| 5.0mm | 2.12x | 22.3% | Marginal |
Across the entire 2mm depth range the F=254mm lens keeps energy density above 64%. With 1mm of negative defocus, energy stays above 87.7% throughout — deep engraving is efficient and uniform from start to finish.
6. How to Find the Balance in This Contradiction?
The core contradiction of deep engraving:
– A small spot needs a short focal length → shallow DOF → cannot engrave deep
– A large DOF needs a long focal length → large spot → low energy density
The key to balance is not “choosing the shortest” or “choosing the longest”, but making sure the theoretical DOF covers both ends of the engraving depth, then applying the negative-defocus technique, and only then pursuing the smallest possible spot.
6.1 Selection Principle: DOF First + Negative Defocus
Theoretical DOF ≥ target depth is the minimum requirement. Combined with the negative-defocus technique (focus set at the depth midpoint), the surface and the bottom receive equal energy density, and the actual result far outperforms focusing on the surface:
5. The Real Performance of a Short-Focal-Length Lens: Shallower and Shallower
With an F=70mm short-focal-length lens, the most typical symptom in deep engraving is that the engraving gets shallower the deeper you go:
| Depth | Spot expansion factor | Energy density (% of focal value) | Actual result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0mm (surface) | 1.00x | 100% | Normal engraving |
| 0.1mm | 1.11x | 80.5% | Acceptable |
| 0.2mm | 1.40x | 50.8% | Clearly shallower |
| 0.3mm | 1.78x | 31.5% | Marginal |
| 0.5mm | 2.66x | 14.2% | Hardly removes material |
| 0.8mm | 4.06x | 6.1% | Essentially ineffective |
| 1.0mm | 5.02x | 4.0% | Completely ineffective |
| 2.0mm | 9.89x | 1.0% | Cannot remove material at all |
At 0.2mm depth the F=70mm lens already has only half its energy left, and beyond 0.5mm it can hardly remove material effectively. This is why deep holes made with a short-focal-length lens so often come out “wide at the top, narrow at the bottom, and unable to cut through” — plenty of energy at the top cuts a wide groove, the energy weakens with depth so the groove narrows, and in the end it stops cutting altogether.
7. Practical Recommendations: Options for Engraving 2mm Deep on a 50×50mm Product
| Option | F-Theta lens | Focus strategy | Spot | Minimum energy from 0 to 2mm | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Option A | F=254mm | 1mm negative defocus | 73.7μm | 87.7% | ⭐Recommended. Energy above 87% throughout, simplest and most reliable, no extra hardware needed |
| Option B | F=160mm + Z axis | Z-axis dynamic focusing | 46.4μm | Follows | Small spot + focus tracking, highest precision, requires Z-axis hardware |
| Option C | F=160mm | 1mm negative defocus | 46.4μm | 53.0% | Usable. Smaller spot, but the minimum energy is 53% throughout; raise the power appropriately to compensate |
| ✗Option D | F=70mm | 1mm negative defocus | 20.3μm | 4.0% | ❌ Even negative defocus cannot save it: DOF only 0.41mm, cannot cut 2mm deep at all |
💡 About the work area: the customer may worry that the F=254mm lens has too large a work area (175×175mm) and is “wasted” on a 50×50mm product. But a large work area does not hurt small-area precision; on the contrary, the more generous DOF makes deep engraving perform even better. A lens’s work area is its “maximum capability”, not “the only size it can mark”.
💡 About negative defocus: Options A and C both require the negative-defocus move — focus on the surface with the red pointer first, then lower the Z axis/column by 1mm. This is a fundamental skill of deep engraving; it needs no extra hardware and any machine can do it.
💡 Option B vs Option A: if the machine has Z-axis dynamic focusing, Option B is theoretically optimal (the focus always follows and the spot is smaller); without a Z axis, Option A is the most worry-free — the negative-defocus performance of the F=254mm lens is already excellent, and an energy density above 87% throughout is ample for most applications.
| Target depth | Negative defocus | Minimum DOF required | Recommended focal length |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.2mm | 0.1mm | ≥0.2mm | F=70mm barely usable (DOF=0.41mm) |
| 0.5mm | 0.25mm | ≥0.5mm | F=100mm; F=160mm recommended |
| 1.0mm | 0.5mm | ≥1.0mm | F=160mm (DOF=2.12mm, 0.5mm negative defocus) |
| 2.0mm | 1.0mm | ≥2.0mm | F=254mm (1mm negative defocus, ≥87.7% throughout); F=160mm also usable (1mm negative defocus, ≥53% throughout, power compensation needed) |
| 3.0mm | 1.5mm | ≥3.0mm | F=254mm (1.5mm negative defocus) or Z-axis dynamic focusing |
| 5.0mm | 2.5mm | ≥5.0mm | F=254mm usable at its limit; Z-axis dynamic focusing recommended |
Back to the customer’s question: for a 50×50mm area engraved 2mm deep, F=254mm with 1mm of negative defocus is the best solution — energy above 87.7% throughout, simple and reliable. F=160mm with 1mm of negative defocus also works, with a minimum of 53% throughout, provided the laser power is raised appropriately to compensate.
6.2 Beam Expanders: Handle with Care, Not a Cure-All
Many people assume a beam expander shrinks the spot without affecting the depth of focus. That is wrong.
Spot Φ₀ = 4M²λf/(πΦ); DOF = 2πw₀²/(M²λ). The smaller the spot, the shallower the DOF — no beam expander can get around this rule.
Now add a 2× beam expander in front of the F=160mm lens (Φ goes from 7mm to 14mm):
| Parameter | F=160mm, no expander | F=160mm, +2× expander |
|---|---|---|
| Focused spot | 46.4 μm | 23.2 μm (halved) |
| Theoretical DOF | 2.12 mm | 0.53 mm (reduced 4×) |
The spot is indeed smaller, but the theoretical DOF plummets from 2.12mm to 0.53mm — it cannot even reach 1mm, so it is completely unusable for deep engraving.
The right way to think about beam expanders: spot size and DOF are two ends of a seesaw; press one end down with an expander and the other end inevitably rises. In deep engraving the DOF is a hard constraint — never trade it away for a smaller spot.
But a beam expander does have one legitimate use: keeping the same spot size while using a longer focal length to obtain a larger work area. For example, an F=160mm lens paired with a beam expander of suitable magnification can deliver the same spot size as a small F=70mm lens across a 110×110mm work area, with the DOF unchanged — but this trades work area for it; the smaller spot does not come free.
6.3 The True Ultimate Solution: Z-Axis Dynamic Focusing
Negative defocus solves the focal-position problem, but the focus remains fixed at one point — as the engraving depth grows, the working surface still drifts steadily away from the focus. The more advanced solution is to make the focus move downward along with the process:
– Z-axis dynamic focusing: after each increment of depth, the Z axis moves down automatically, keeping the focus always on the working surface
– Paired with an F=160mm lens plus Z-axis stepping, 2mm or even 5mm deep engraving becomes easy
– At that point the difference between short and medium focal lengths is no longer fatal, because the focus always follows
– If the machine has Z-axis dynamic focusing, it is the optimal solution for deep engraving — it combines the high energy density of a small spot with the uniformity of a focus that follows throughout
8. Summary
| Misconception | Reality |
|---|---|
| A short-focal-length lens has a small spot, so it engraves deeper | Small spot ≠ deeper engraving. Without enough DOF, energy density at depth falls off a cliff, and the result is actually shallower |
| The focus must be set on the material surface | Negative defocus (focus at the depth midpoint) is the fundamental operation of deep engraving: surface and bottom energy are equal and at their maximum, with uniformity and efficiency far superior to focusing on the surface |
| The F=70mm lens suits deep engraving | The F=70mm lens has a theoretical DOF of only 0.41mm; after negative defocus the surface and bottom both get just 4% — completely unusable for deep engraving |
| The F=160mm lens barely manages a 2mm depth | With the focus on the surface the bottom gets only 22% — indeed marginal — but after 1mm of negative defocus the minimum is 53% throughout, so it is usable |
| Pick the shortest focal length for deep engraving | For deep engraving, prefer medium-to-long focal lengths with ample DOF and combine them with negative defocus to ensure energy density throughout |
| A beam expander shrinks the spot while keeping the DOF | A beam expander shrinks the spot but inevitably shrinks the DOF too — the opposite of what deep engraving needs |



Leave a Reply